Skip to main content
Apple iPhone 17

AppleGood TimingGood Time to Buy — Early in the product cycle

iPhone 17

8.7/10
Based on 11 reviews

Affiliate Disclosure: We may earn a commission when you buy through links on our site. This does not influence our editorial recommendations. Learn more about how we make money

8.0

Clara’s Verdict

Excellent

A genuinely solid upgrade with a beautiful display, great cameras, and all-day battery that won't break the bank.

Best for: Busy parents who need reliable battery and great photos, Anyone upgrading from an older iPhone, People who want flagship features without flagship prices

Skip if: Photography enthusiasts who need telephoto zoom, People who just bought an iPhone 16

7.2

Ethan’s Verdict

Very Good

Solid performance and battery gains can't overcome minimal design changes and half-baked AI that falls behind competitors.

Best for: iPhone 16 owners wanting a meaningful upgrade, Users prioritizing battery life over innovation, People locked into the Apple ecosystem

Skip if: Design-conscious buyers, Those wanting cutting-edge AI features, Budget-conscious shoppers with iPhone 16 available

Clara’s Pros & Cons

  • +Stunning 120Hz display that's bright and beautiful
  • +Excellent dual cameras capture sharp, colorful everyday photos
  • +Battery easily lasts all day with faster charging
  • +Premium design feels solid without the premium price tag
  • No telephoto camera for zoom photography
  • Apple Intelligence still feels incomplete and unfinished
  • Minimal design changes from iPhone 16
  • USB-C stuck at slower 2.0 speeds on this model

Ethan’s Pros & Cons

  • +Battery life easily lasts 24+ hours with real-world use
  • +Display is genuinely excellent with 120Hz and 3000-nit peak
  • +48MP cameras produce sharp, detailed images in good light
  • +Outperforms Galaxy S25 and Pixel 10 in CPU benchmarks
  • No telephoto camera on a $829 flagship is a major step back
  • Apple Intelligence feels incomplete compared to competitors
  • Minimal design changes make this feel like a refresh
  • USB 2.0 port speeds are unacceptable at this price point

Score Breakdown

Performance
8.010% wt
Display
8.514% wt
Camera
8.524% wt
Battery Life
8.514% wt
Design & Build
8.019% wt
Software & Features
7.55% wt
Value
8.514% wt

Score Breakdown

Performance
8.020% wt
Display
8.515% wt
Camera
7.815% wt
Battery Life
8.515% wt
Design & Build
7.010% wt
Software & Features
6.515% wt
Value
7.010% wt

Clara’s Full Review

The iPhone 17 Is the Everyday Phone We've Been Waiting For

Honestly, the iPhone 17 feels like the phone Apple should have made last year. It's not flashy or revolutionary, but it's genuinely good at the things you actually do every day.

Let's talk about that display first because it's a real standout. Reviewers rave about the 6.1-inch Super Retina XDR screen with its 120Hz refresh rate making everything feel smooth and responsive. The contrast is noticeably improved, and the 3,000-nit peak brightness means you can actually see it when you're scrolling through Instagram at the park or checking messages during carpool. It's the kind of screen that makes you want to use your phone more, which sounds silly but matters.

The cameras are where this phone really shines for families. The new 48MP main camera and 48MP ultrawide capture sharp, naturally colored photos without you having to fiddle with settings. Reviewers specifically praise how it handles bright sunlight, keeping shadows and highlights balanced, and the portrait mode adds nice depth to those quick kid shots. The ultrawide is a huge upgrade from previous models, giving you way more flexibility for group photos. The only real miss is no telephoto camera, so if you love zooming in, you'll notice that.

Battery life is genuinely impressive. Reviewers report it lasting over a day with regular use and up to 30 hours of video playback. That means during a busy day of texts, photos, scrolling, and calls, you're not stressing about finding a charger. The faster 30W charging tops you up in about an hour, which is convenient when you need a quick boost.

What I appreciate about the design is how it balances premium feel with practicality. The matte finish looks great and doesn't show fingerprints like glossy phones do. It's compact and comfortable to hold. The IP68 rating means it survives splashes and spills, which if you have kids, is basically essential.

Now the real talk: this doesn't feel like a huge leap from the iPhone 16. The design is basically the same, and while that's not necessarily bad, you're not getting a "wow" moment. Apple Intelligence is still kind of half-baked and doesn't feel as integrated as competitors are doing it. And honestly, the USB-C port being stuck at USB 2.0 speeds feels cheap when the Pro models get USB 3.0.

But here's the thing: at $829, you're getting a phone that looks beautiful, takes gorgeous photos, lasts all day, and feels premium without costing a thousand dollars. For busy people who just want something that works reliably and doesn't require a tech degree to use, that's actually perfect.

Clara Mercer, Home & Lifestyle Editor

Ethan’s Full Review

A Competent Upgrade That Doesn't Justify the Price

The iPhone 17 is a textbook case of iterative improvement masquerading as innovation. Apple has made genuine gains in three areas: battery endurance, display quality, and camera resolution. But the business case for upgrading from the iPhone 16 is weak, and the software story actively works against the hardware.

Let's start with what works. Battery life is legitimately impressive. PCMag measured 24 hours and 31 minutes under video streaming, while What Hi-Fi reports up to 30 hours of video playback. That's the kind of all-day performance you can actually rely on, and the 30W wired charging reaching full battery in one hour is convenient. CNET confirms this isn't a fluke, noting the device lasts over a day with regular use. This is the phone's strongest technical achievement.

The display is also worth attention. The 1-120Hz ProMotion with 3,000-nit peak brightness and variable refresh rate delivers genuine visual improvements over the iPhone 16. What Hi-Fi specifically highlights improved contrast and sharper images, with balanced yet rich colors. This is a pro-level screen at a non-pro price, which matters.

Here's where the problems start. The dual 48MP camera system is a resolution upgrade, not a capability upgrade. You get sharper images and the ultrawide now matches the main camera in megapixel count, which is fine. But the complete absence of telephoto on a flagship phone is inexcusable. Apple's offering a 2x portrait mode through digital cropping, but that's not a substitute for optical zoom. The iPhone 16 had this problem too, and it's still a problem here.

The real issue is Apple Intelligence. Multiple reviewers describe it as "half-baked" and "a work in progress." What Hi-Fi notes it lacks the integration seen in competitors' offerings. At $829, you're paying flagship prices for software features that feel like beta releases. Samsung and Google have moved faster here, and it shows.

Design-wise, there's almost nothing new. The matte finish and compact form factor are fine, but this is now the second year with minimal visual changes. The industrial design feels stale. Meanwhile, Apple still ships with USB 2.0 speeds on the port, which is unforgivable when Pro models offer USB 3.0. That's a cost-cutting measure that's visible to anyone who tries to transfer data.

The pricing math doesn't work either. The iPhone 16 remains available at lower cost, and the feature differences don't justify the $100+ gap. CNET calls this the "best value among iPhone 17 models," but that's a low bar when the entire lineup is expensive. At $829, you're competing directly with the Galaxy S25 and Pixel 10, both of which offer better AI integration and more thoughtful feature sets.

Bottom line: the iPhone 17 is a competent phone that improves on its predecessor in measurable ways. Battery life is excellent, the display is genuinely good, and performance is solid. But the lack of design evolution, incomplete software features, and missing telephoto make this feel like a phone that's coasting on brand loyalty rather than pushing forward. It's a good phone for people already committed to Apple. For everyone else, the upgrade math is unconvincing.

Ethan Mercer, Editor-in-Chief

Specifications

cameraDual 48MP + 12MP
batteryUp to 20 hours video playback
display6.1-inch Super Retina XDR
processorA17 Bionic
storage options128GB, 256GB, 512GB

Overall Rating

8.7
out of 10
Clara
8.0
Ethan
7.2
Critics (9)
9.0

Related Reviews

Head-to-Head Comparisons

Alternatives Worth Considering

iPhone 16
Better for: Budget-conscious buyers who don't need the latest upgradesTradeoff: Older display technology, less advanced cameras, but saves you money
Samsung Galaxy S25 Plus
Better for: Android users who want flagship features and more zoom optionsTradeoff: Different ecosystem, but arguably better camera zoom capabilities
iPhone 17 Pro
Better for: People who want telephoto zoom and the absolute best camera systemTradeoff: Costs significantly more, but you get professional-grade features
Samsung Galaxy S25
Better for: Users wanting better AI integration and telephoto capabilitiesTradeoff: You lose the Apple ecosystem and may face a learning curve, but gain more mature AI features and optical zoom
Google Pixel 10
Better for: Photography enthusiasts who prioritize computational photographyTradeoff: CPU performance is slightly lower, but Google's AI-driven camera processing is more advanced

Review History

Initial review from real source data

Initial review from real source data

Editorial Independence

Our reviews are based on research from trusted expert sources. We may earn commissions from affiliate links, but this never influences our ratings or recommendations. How we score · Editorial policy · Report an error

Related Smartphones

SamsungDeals LikelyNewer model likely available — look for deals on this one

Galaxy S25 Ultra

Samsung Galaxy S25 Ultra
8.9/10
$1049.99

GoogleGood TimingGood Time to Buy — Early in the product cycle

Pixel 10 Pro XL

Google Pixel 10 Pro XL
8.5/10
$899.00

OnePlusNew ReleaseJust Released — Great time to buy the latest model

15

OnePlus 15
8.5/10
$999.99

AppleDeals LikelyNewer model likely available — look for deals on this one

iPhone 16 Pro Max

Apple iPhone 16 Pro Max
8.4/10
$799.99
$799

Lowest Price Vendor Auto-Selected