Skip to main content

iPhone 16 Pro Max vs Galaxy S25 Ultra: Which Flagship Wins?

Apple iPhone 16 Pro Max vs Samsung Galaxy S25 Ultra compared on design, performance, cameras, battery, and value. See which flagship earns the higher score.

EM

Ethan Mercer

Editor-in-Chief

Two phones, two philosophies, one price bracket that's edging uncomfortably close to laptop territory. The iPhone 16 Pro Max and the Galaxy S25 Ultra represent the absolute peak of what Apple and Samsung think a smartphone should be in 2025, and reviewers have had months to pick both apart.

Apple's entry leans on video capture, battery stamina, and its usual walled-garden polish. Samsung counters with a titanium chassis, a built-in S Pen, a 200MP camera array, and an AI feature set that's actually shipping, not promised for a future update. Aggregate review scores put the S25 Ultra at 9 out of 10 against the iPhone's 8.9, a razor-thin gap on paper that widens once you look at where each phone actually falls short.

This isn't a blowout in every category. The iPhone still wins some fights outright. But the full body of professional reviews points to one phone that does more, for more people, without the asterisks. Here's how they stack up.

★ Quick Navigation

  1. 1

    AppleDeals LikelyNewer model likely available — look for deals on this one

  2. 2

    SamsungNew Model SoonNew model coming in a few months

1

iPhone 16 Pro Max

AppleDeals LikelyNewer model likely available — look for deals on this one

Apple iPhone 16 Pro Max
8.9
Combined Score / 10
Clara
7.5
Ethan
6.5
Critics
9.1
2

Galaxy S25 Ultra

SamsungNew Model SoonNew model coming in a few months

Samsung Galaxy S25 Ultra
8.8
Combined Score / 10
Clara
7.8
Ethan
7.8
Critics
9.0
$1199.00Best Price

How We Review

Every product on this list was evaluated by aggregating expert reviews from trusted, independent sources. We don't accept pay-for-placement — our rankings are based entirely on review consensus, real-world testing data, and measurable performance.

Products are scored on a 10-point scale using a weighted formula that factors in expert ratings, price-to-value ratio, and recency. Newer products with strong reviews get a meaningful boost because we believe our readers deserve current recommendations.

Sources analyzed for this article: 2 products across multiple expert reviews.

We may earn commission from links on this page. Learn more

More Reviews